Connect with us


'Why has education become so political?' And other questions you have about Indiana Senate Bill No. 167 – Observer Online



The Observer is a student-run, daily print & online newspaper serving Notre Dame, Saint Mary’s & Holy Cross. Learn about us.
| Thursday, January 13, 2022
Editor’s Note: Due to a copy editing error, part of the last sentence was originally left out of this piece. It has since been added. The Observer apologizes for this error.
I’ve attended Indiana schools for just shy of 17 years. This week, Indiana Senate Education Bill 167, and the surrounding debate, made national headlines. I read the bill thoroughly.
Concurrently, I read an op-ed by Tucker Carlson on “the extremely left-wing to the outright totalitarian” curricula taught in “so many” American schools. Carlson informed his readers and me that some schools have “eliminated biology” and are “teaching children that biology isn’t real.” If these statements about the crisis of biology education were true, I would be highly concerned. Especially given the public health crisis our nation has endured throughout the past two years due to the COVID-19 pandemic. However, parents should take heart that in Indiana, as well as the vast majority of states in the U.S., students are still required to take biology in order to earn their diplomas.
Senate Bill 167 isn’t about biology, though. It’s mostly about setting limits on how topics such as race, ethnicity, class, sex and gender can be broached in the classroom. Mostly.
But one element of this bill may hurt students by instituting an access barrier to mental, emotional or psychological care. The bill “provides that before a school corporation or qualified school may provide or administer certain mental, social-emotional, or psychological services to a student, the school must provide the parent of the student or the student, if the student is an adult or an emancipated minor, with a written request for consent to provide or administer certain mental, social-emotional, or psychological services.”
I fully appreciate the intent for greater parental involvement in decisions regarding their children’s health, but we cannot ignore cases where children may be put at higher risk as a consequence. Schools are a major reporter of child abuse. According to Education Week, during the virtual schooling phase of the pandemic — between 2019 and 2020 — reports of child abuse decreased significantly, while “confirmed evidence of abuse” and suspected incidents “considered severe enough to need medical evaluations and intervention” increased by 30% and 7% respectively. If school counselors and teachers must obtain parental consent before administering mental, social-emotional or psychological help to a student living in an abusive household, the results could be disastrous, possibly intensifying the degree of abuse or psychological distress the child faces.
Another element of the bill legally limits the freedoms of schools and educators, as it “Removes schools and certain public libraries from the list of entities eligible for a specified defense to criminal prosecutions alleging:
(1) the dissemination of material harmful to minors; or
(2) a performance harmful to minors.”
The bill simultaneously makes colleges and universities eligible for defenses against the same two criminal prosecutions.
The combination of these actions implies a stronger exertion of control over the information that young children are allowed to consume, while giving greater freedom to colleges and universities against similar charges of disseminating material deemed obscene or harmful to minors (the latter of which lacks bite, since most college students aren’t minors).
The argument for limiting child exposure to specifically explicit, violent or otherwise mature material in the classroom is clear and well-taken. Other material? Not so much. Not in a free society. I can’t help but think of the irony. This bill, which in the words of Republican senator Scott Baldwin is “trying to say that we should not tell kids what to think about politics,” removes any defenses schools can have against the same charge which killed Socrates: corrupting the youth. Socrates, who said famously that the unexamined life was not worth living; Socrates, who exercised freedom of thought and taught his students to do so; Socrates, who paid the ultimate price for it.
What is a Good Education?
“[A]sk in general what great benefit the state derives from the training by which it educates its citizens, and the reply will be perfectly straightforward. The good education they have received will make them good men…” (Plato, Laws, 641b7–10, retrieved from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy).
In response to those who ask why education become has so political, my answer is that it always has been. The task of those selecting which facts, which curricula, which courses of study our children will be taught, out of all possible courses of study and facts and curricula our children could be taught, is herculean. A world in which every student learns every fact from every perspective is unfathomable. So, the sliver of facts about the world that our children learn in American K-12 schools is curated by adults who have their own share of biases, political values and ideas that affect what gets included and what gets left out.
In a statistical sense, truly unbiased education would either warrant that: a) Students should learn every possible thing, every possible recorded fact (impossible) or, b) that facts about the world be selected at random and taught to our children. Of course, these are not the outcomes lawmakers, school administrators and parents have in mind when they call for “less biased education” or “unbiased facts.” But the reality is, even in some hypothetical scenario where 50% of what is chosen to be taught accords with “conservative” viewpoints, and 50% of what is taught accords with “liberal” viewpoints on contentious social issues, such an education would be strongly biased. Our country’s obsession with left vs. right curriculum wars instills a binary partisan animosity into our children, in effect turning them into young soldiers for the political commitments of their parents, who fear that their teachers will do it first.
Renee Yaseen is a senior economics major with minors in theology and PPE (Philosophy, Politics, and Economics). In her free time, she writes poems, hangs out with loved ones and ponders the view from her undisclosed study spot in [redacted] Hall. Please send all comments, diatribes and warm fuzzies to [email protected].
The views expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer.
Share This Story
About Renee Yaseen

Starting in 2012, most of the United States adopted the Common Core State Standards. CCSS,…
Hide Sidebar
To uncover the truth and report it accurately.
Site Links
Like what you see? Help support student-run publications.
Phone: (574) 631-7471 / Fax: (574) 631-6927 / Address: The Observer / P.O. Box 779 / Notre Dame, IN 46556
Email: [email protected]


Continue Reading
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply


TOP 4 Essay Writing Services in the USA: 2023 Edition



essay writing services reddit

As an increasing number of students seek assistance with their academic assignments, the demand for reliable essay writing services continues to grow. With so many options available, it can be challenging to identify the best service providers. To help you make an informed decision, we have compiled a list of the top 4 essay writing services in the USA for 2023. These services have been carefully evaluated based on their reputation, quality of work, customer satisfaction, and affordability. Read on to discover the top essay writing services that can provide you with the support you need to excel in your academic journey.

essay writing services reddit

essay writing services reddit

What Makes a Great Essay Writing Service

Before delving into the top essay writing services reddit, it’s essential to understand the criteria we used to evaluate them. A great essay-writing service should possess the following qualities:

  • Quality of Work: The service should deliver well-researched, original, and high-quality essays that meet academic standards.
  • Professional Writers: The service should have a team of qualified writers with expertise in various subjects who can handle diverse topics.
  • Timely Delivery: The service should be reliable and capable of delivering essays within the given deadline.
  • Customer Support: The service should provide excellent customer support, ensuring effective communication throughout the writing process.
  • Affordability: The service should offer reasonable pricing plans that are affordable for students while maintaining the quality of work.

Now, let’s explore the top 4 essay writing services in the USA for 2023.

TOP 4 Essay Writing Services in the USA: 2023 Edition

2.1 EssayPro

EssayPro is a highly reputable essay writing service known for its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. They have a diverse team of experienced writers who can handle a wide range of subjects. EssayPro offers a user-friendly platform, allowing students to place orders easily and track the progress of their essays. Their pricing is competitive, and they offer additional features such as plagiarism reports and unlimited revisions.

2.2 Grademiners

Grademiners is a popular choice among students due to its excellent track record and reliability. They have a team of highly skilled writers who are proficient in various academic disciplines. Grademiners ensures on-time delivery and provides 24/7 customer support to address any concerns. They also offer free revisions and a money-back guarantee, ensuring customer satisfaction.

2.3 Ultius

Ultius is known for its exceptional writing services and commitment to customer privacy and security. They have a rigorous writer selection process, ensuring that only qualified professionals handle the essays. Ultius offers a wide range of writing services, including essay writing, editing, and proofreading. They also provide a mobile app for convenient communication and order tracking.

2.4 EduBirdie

EduBirdie is a trusted essay writing service that offers a unique feature called “choose your own writer.” Students can browse through profiles and select a writer who matches their requirements. This personalized approach allows for effective collaboration and ensures that the final essay meets the student’s expectations. EduBirdie also provides 24/7 customer support and guarantees 100% original and plagiarism-free content.

How We Evaluated the Services

To evaluate the essay writing services, we considered several factors, including:

  • Reputation and reliability
  • Quality of work and adherence to academic standards
  • Customer reviews and satisfaction
  • Pricing and affordability
  • Additional features and guarantees
  • Customer support and communication

By carefully analyzing these aspects, we identified the top 4 essay writing services that offer outstanding support to students.


Choosing a reliable essay writing service is crucial for students seeking academic assistance. The top 4 essay writing services mentioned in this article – EssayPro, Grademiners, Ultius, and EduBirdie – have proven their worth in terms of quality, reliability, and customer satisfaction. Whether you need help with an essay, research paper, or any other academic assignment, these services can provide you with the support you need to succeed in your studies.

Continue Reading


%d bloggers like this: